If the threshold sits at or below your current average order value, you're giving away free shipping on orders that would have happened anyway — it's not changing behavior, just cutting margin on your typical order.
Setting it 15-25% above current AOV gives customers a genuine reason to add one more item, which is where the feature actually earns its cost instead of just subsidizing orders that didn't need the nudge.
A threshold that only shows up as a surprise at checkout doesn't influence behavior — a progress indicator visible in the cart ("$12 more for free shipping") is what actually drives the extra add, not the policy existing somewhere in the fine print.